1886 Crescent Hotel, Arkansas: History and the Ghosts of Eureka Springs

The stone 1886 Crescent Hotel and its roadside sign in Eureka Springs, Arkansas

At a glance

  • Location: 75 Prospect Avenue, on a hilltop above downtown Eureka Springs, Arkansas
  • Opened: May 1, 1886, as a luxury resort for the Eureka Springs mineral-water boom
  • Later lives: Crescent College and Conservatory for Women (from 1908), and Norman Baker’s fraudulent “cancer hospital” (1937 to 1940)
  • Listed: National Register of Historic Places (2016)
  • Best known for: calling itself “America’s Most Haunted Hotel,” with Michael in Room 218, Theodora in Room 419 and the ghosts of the Baker years
  • Ghost tours: nightly, from $29.50 plus tax, open to non-guests

History

In the 1880s Eureka Springs was one of the most talked-about health resorts in the country. The town had grown up almost overnight after 1879 around dozens of springs that people believed could heal. Visitors came by the thousands to drink and bathe in its mineral springs, and investors wanted a hotel to match the crowds. According to the Encyclopedia of Arkansas, the Eureka Improvement Company, led by former Arkansas governor Powell Clayton, built the Crescent on 27 acres on a ridge overlooking the town. The architect was Isaac S. Taylor of St. Louis. The walls are 18-inch-thick blocks of limestone, cut by Irish stonemasons from a quarry on the White River near Beaver. The project cost $294,000.

The hotel opened on May 1, 1886, and a formal banquet honored the Republican politician James G. Blaine later that month. Guests found electric lights, an elevator, gardens, stables and the kind of luxury that the Ozarks had never seen. The resort boom did not last. By the early 1900s fewer visitors were coming to take the waters, and the hotel needed another source of income.

From 1908 the Crescent doubled as Crescent College and Conservatory for Women, a boarding school that ran during the school year while the hotel served summer guests. An advertisement quoted by the Encyclopedia of Arkansas promised a “$300,000 fireproof building,” rooms with private baths and an elevator. Smithsonian magazine dates the college to 1908 through 1924. It later reopened as a junior college for a few years around 1930, though sources differ on exactly when it closed.

The darkest chapter began in 1937. Norman Baker, a self-promoting radio broadcaster who had been run out of Iowa by the medical authorities, bought the empty hotel and reopened it as the Baker Hospital. His brochures promised that cancer could be cured “without the knife,” and he called the area “the Switzerland of America.” Baker was not a doctor. Smithsonian reports that his “Formula 5” was a mix of alcohol, glycerol, carbolic acid, ground watermelon seed, corn silk and clover leaves, injected at the site of the cancer up to seven times a day. It did nothing. Desperate patients paid cash, and Smithsonian says Baker took in about $10 million.

On September 1, 1939, Baker was arrested for mail fraud, because of his brochures. He was convicted in 1940 and served four years in Leavenworth. He died in Florida in 1958, of cirrhosis and cancer.

The hotel reopened as a resort in 1946. A fire damaged the fourth floor in 1967, and the building went through several owners and long periods of decline. In 1997 Marty and Elise Roenigk bought it and began a long restoration, which the hotel continues today with its New Moon Spa. The Crescent was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 2016.

In 2019, a groundskeeper digging at the edge of the woods behind the hotel unearthed hundreds of old specimen bottles and jars, some still holding liquid. They dated from the Baker years. Smithsonian reported that many similar jars, holding unidentifiable bits of flesh, had once been displayed in the hospital lobby. Keith Scales, who runs the hotel’s ghost tours and plays Baker in a one-man show, told the magazine he thinks they hold pig parts from a butcher, not surgical specimens.

The ghost stories (reported folklore)

Michael, Room 218. The best-known ghost is Michael, said to be an Irish stonemason who fell to his death while the hotel was being built. Smithsonian describes him as a flirt who is “now and forever romancing guests” in Room 218, which the hotel’s tour site names as one of its haunted rooms. No record of a worker’s death during construction has been identified in the sources we reviewed.

Theodora, Room 419. The hotel’s own tour site names Theodora as one of its best-known spirits. In the story she is a Baker-era patient who is still looking for her key outside Room 419, and who, Smithsonian says, packs guests’ suitcases when she is annoyed.

The nurse and the morgue. A nurse is said to push a gurney along the third floor at night. The hotel’s tour site calls the old morgue, a cool, low-ceilinged room from the Baker era, one of the most active areas in the building. Smithsonian notes that it was probably a pantry, used to hold bodies until the funeral home’s hearse arrived.

Norman Baker and the others. Baker himself is said to linger near the old recreation room, and a bearded man is reported in the lobby and the bar. A little boy named Breckie is said to play in the halls and appear in guests’ photos.

The Girl in the Mist. The most dramatic story is of a young woman who falls or leaps from an east-side balcony into the garden, wrapped in mist, around 10:30 on moonlit nights. Some versions make her a student from the college years. Smithsonian is blunt: there is no record of any such event at the hotel, and no evidence that any student fell.

On TV. Wikipedia says a 2005 Ghost Hunters episode claimed to capture an apparition on a thermal camera. Smithsonian describes a TV “ghost sighting” in the morgue that now plays there on a loop.

How strong is the lore? Strong as a tradition, weak as evidence. The Baker fraud is real and well documented, and it gives the hotel a genuinely disturbing history. The Encyclopedia of Arkansas notes that ghost reports increased in the 1990s, when the hotel was being restored and promoted. Most of the named ghosts have no documented person behind them, and Smithsonian points out that the hotel’s marketing turns Baker’s crimes into a selling point. That is worth keeping in mind on the tour. The most unsettling story here is not a ghost at all. It is the record of sick people who paid a con man for a cure that did not exist, in rooms you can now book for the night.

Visiting

  • Address and phone: 75 Prospect Avenue, Eureka Springs, AR 72632. Ghost tour line: 877-342-9766.
  • Ghost tours: the hotel’s ghost tour site lists the regular Crescent Hotel Ghost Tour at $29.50 plus tax, a 10 p.m. Expert and Expanded Tour at $35 plus tax, a Midnight Investigation at $39.50 plus tax, and a Kids Ghost Tour at $15 on Fridays and Saturdays (accompanying adult free). Tours sell out, so buy tickets in advance.
  • Ages: regular tours are recommended for ages 8 and up. Under-16s must be accompanied by an adult chaperone aged 21 or older. Group rates are available for 10 or more people.
  • Before you go: tours start on the fourth floor, near the Sky Bar. No alcohol is allowed on the tour. If you need wheelchair access, call ahead so staff can suggest a tour time.
  • Photos: the tour site says photos are for personal use only. Rebroadcasting or republishing videos, pictures or accounts of the tour requires the hotel’s written permission.

FAQ

Is the Crescent Hotel really haunted?

It markets itself as America’s most haunted hotel, and guests report many experiences. The named ghosts are folklore; the Norman Baker years are real history.

Was the Crescent really a cancer hospital?

Yes, in name. From 1937 to 1940 it housed Norman Baker’s fraudulent “hospital.” He was not a doctor, his cure did nothing, and he went to prison for mail fraud.

Can you take the ghost tour without staying at the hotel?

Yes. The tours are open to the public, and tickets are sold online.

Which rooms are said to be the most haunted?

The hotel’s tour site points to Room 218, linked to the stonemason Michael, and Room 419, linked to Theodora, along with the old morgue from the Baker years. Both rooms are bookable guest rooms, and the morgue is visited on the ghost tours. Ask about availability early if you want one of the named rooms, especially around Halloween.

More haunted hotels

Read about The Biltmore in Coral Gables and the Hotel del Coronado.

Sources

Postcard view of the Crescent Hotel in Eureka Springs, Arkansas, around 1886
Photo: Unknown author via Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)

Shop the gear

Heads up: NicheStuff is our own shop, so we earn from purchases made through these links. Prices and availability are set on the store and can change.

Top image: Photo: Alan Islas via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0)